Construction or suppression

by | Aug 24, 2018


Providing information is constructive.

Withholding information is destructive.

Both these statement can be right or wrong, depending on the intention of the information.

Without any awareness, my mother contributed to increasing the global dog training skills. Her choice for shaping me as a child was the well-known protocol of “she should know what she did wrong” school of philosophy. The fallout was very little desire to trying to get it right, for her. It was specific to that person, as achieving acknowledgement from other people was, and still is, thriving.

The long-term effect was an aversion to withholding information from the dog that would help them find solutions. I could not see the advantages in punishing a dog for the “wrong” behaviours if they did not know what was the “right” behaviour. We have all seen the horrendous fallout of that strategy, and probably experienced it as well.

Our experience as learners will have an impact on our choices as teachers, or trainers: facilitating learning on a specific pathway. The destination of that pathway and how we set up the journey are often a product of our own learning experiences.

There are times when a flood of information is not useful, and as teachers we need to select the most salient information for that person, or dog, at that time, but a total absence of information does not serve learning progress.

There are times when getting it wrong does not need a post mortem, but neither is there any gain from silence. There are so many varieties of silence. We have an entire vocabulary to describe silence: pregnant pause, dead silence, quiet silence, frozen silence, punishing silence.

Clicker training was floating around the internet well beyond my childhood and I was already enjoying a training philosophy of construction rather than removal or suppression of undesired responses. I have always wanted to build learners that moved towards something rather than moving away from something.

I like the visualisation that if you are moving in a direction are you going toward “B” or away from “A”? The travelling looks the same, but the motivation is completely opposite.

Are we running to B or away from A?

The recommend policy of withholding a click to extend duration was surely a backward step, going against the grain or swallowing the wrong way. It certainly made me uncomfortable to apply it and I saw confusion from the learners.

Even when new information presents clear results we have some hesitation in embracing it. That stepping back sensation is a need to collate this new information with our current beliefs or understanding and see how they mesh together. We either then step forward, cement our previous beliefs and walk away or make a blend of the two. Often this can be a delay whilst we digest, feel a need to discuss and explore with others, or go back and re-source our previous knowledge. Were we wrong, did we interpret it wrong, or was the information wrong or just “of its time”?

Alongside the withheld-click-for-duration was the expectation that this non-information would be interpreted as “offer something else”. This defies dog-logic. Continue with the same thing or offer something else are completely opposing.

Are we running to B or away from A?

The look of dog-logic when “it does not compute”

Necessity is the mother of invention

Creativity often emerges from finding your chair is between the rock and a hard place.

When the options are ethically unavailable we need to create a new pathway. We find that the rock, the corner with paint brush in hand and the hard place are there of our own immobility.

I could not bring myself to sit silently whilst my dogs “tried to work it out”. It seemed like they were supposed to wriggle around with discomfort and non-information until they stumbled, by luck, on the right answer.

I am aware that when I am working on a task that seems inefficient, ineffective or unnecessary  work, I will riddle around all the options. This often means drilling down to the core of the matter and finding clear costs and benefits to all involved. This may be termed creative drive, but pursuing tainted repetition does not seem worth the investment when other options may be available.

It is human nature to strive to be better. It is not my nature to walk a flat learning curve.

It is why I only once experienced the Clicker Game and travelled very fast to invent my table game: also known as Genabacab, You Don’t Say, Portal, Ken’s Training Game and all its cousins. The Clicker Game would have been richly enjoyed by my mother, but not for the right reasons.

The echo of trying to get something right and receiving silence as a response can be a destructive, soul stripping, failure of communication. I would never want to do that to my dogs, and I do not think people should ever experience it as part of their need to learn about clicker training. But we do see learners enjoy this process with their teacher – what is the difference?

There is a significant difference between your printer responding with silence, and person responding with silence. The printer can only do what it can do, it does not build a relationship, or teach or encourage learning skills. It is not there to facilitate your learning. The printer will have a solution, it will be logical and you can roll down the list of possibilities until the right information is provided. It is not trying to punish or make you change your behaviour. It is not personal.

I wanted to explore this new teaching strategy, but I was boxed in by the “withhold the click” advice. I needed to find different ways to communicate.

There were distinctive goals I was seeking.

~ Continual success, always travelling forwards

~ Each click to represent a moment of joy and not a moment of relief from the anxiety of not understanding.

This meant we needed clear, clean information that supported learning and gave it wings.

Microshaping came into the picture. This is my protocol of slicing the learning so finely that the learner never has to experience extinction to learn. Desperately trying to find out what was wanted was a no-go avenue, and the learner was set-up to only experience a successful, continual pathway to the new goal.

We want to build confident learners that enjoy flirting and teasing with their teacher. There is never  “desperately trying”, they see the opportunity as a game and a challenge to inspire. But even these enthusiastic triers will need a solution before their creativity expires.

Merrick is experiencing a demand for finding a solution, and when successful I am using the cue “turn” as the marker. This is not as accurate as a click, but it demonstrates the power of a cue.

More … ?

To extend a behaviour for a longer time, or greater distance travelled, I wanted to be able to construct “more” by building a desire, an enthusiasm, to continue rather than just filing the vacuum of silence.

More information was spilling out during the early years about different protocols and the keep going signal was a common terminology. What confused the learning pool even more was the same term meaning different things to different people.

Sometimes shutting the door to your own laboratory cuts out all the distracting information whilst you sift and riddle the bones of the fire.

I already had the tools to build, extend, lengthen behaviour – the cues and chaining. My interpretation of duration is simple a chain of the same repeating behaviour. By adding cues to small segments we were easily able to construct long segments and build a pleasure in continuing rather than an anxiety about why the click in not coming

Those little doubts that creep in because response is a (dead) silence are hard to remove and may damage a behaviour for life. Silence is very expressive and the dead variety will kill effort, fast, and sometimes fatally.

Destructive or constructive?

Every protocol, procedure, recipe, programme, strategy that gives us instruction, originated from curiosity or necessity. We have to thank not only the designers, who rarely have their name attached, but also the rat, pigeon or dog that drove that creativity.

Application can be destructive or constructive. The deciding factors are:

~ The understanding, function or purpose of the process

~ The skill level and motives behind the application

~ The learner’s experience during application

Looking at the way the behaviour is carried out is the most important element, and that is the product of all the above considerations.



Build the Learning

Lifelong skills built in activities and play. A dog that is curious, confident, resilient with a natural enthusiasm for learning.

rewards skills

Learn about the fascinating landscape of rewards and how to make them the centre of your training and relationship.

Management or Training

Find a pathway to suit your lifestyle of living with dogs. When management temporarilly supports the learning, or choose training.

learn well
learn it once

Setter Members

Access to The Sett community and groups

Discount for all courses and videos 50%

Archives of previous courses and books

Share your learning, upgrade your thinking


Key Reading

Cue Seeking is Connection

Connection is very individual and to be authentic we have to observe, slow down, understand our dogs and meet them where they are.

The Right Bed in the Right Spot

Resting and sleeping are not necessarily the same state. Good sleep where we feel safe and comfortable is important for us all.

Play Health Check

When we look at play or food delivery as an ACTIVITY we share the same mindset as the dog: is there pleasure to be experienced?

Since the Dawn of Dog Training

The old joke reminds us that the only thing dog trainers can agree on is that their training method in the best one. It becomes increasingly difficult to know which method is “right” and whether it will suit the dog, the situation and trainer’s skills.

Back to Basics?

The word “basic” is often derided as synonymous with “shallow,” but in its origins it is the very opposite: foundational, profound, supportive.

The Whole of The Dog

We cannot divide training into compartments of fast recalls, or sit for greeting, or loose leads as everything we ask of the dogs is interrelated.

Not Today and Not for My Sheepdogs

Standard protocols of extinction, impulse control, counterconditioning are quickly grabbed off the shelf as satisfactory solutions. These solutions are unlikely to help your collie, your sheepdog as the focus is heavily on suppression of who they are and why they live.

Do you see what I see

Doing better is the reward from doing the work. This work needs to be the right work at the right time with the right intent done in the right way.

The Cost of Cherrypicking

When we admit that the ideas we’re sharing are derived from the work of others, we demonstrate our own commitment to learning

A Family of Multiple Dogs

Another addition is not just an extra bed and bowl. It is important to build a home that is healthy, content and well-balanced.

Top Training

Evidence of learning

When we use the words “teach” or “train” child, person or dog, the operative term implies that the process is under the ownership of the teacher or trainer. What your teacher thinks you have learned may not be what you actually learned.

One dog watching

The other dog working
or ….how to train the spectators to quietly rest and watch whilst you work, play, teach a single member of the group

The Power of Passive Learning

Active learning: the learner takes active choice of what to do, how to respond, is attentive and making conscious effort
Passive learning: little conscious effort, reward is delivered for minimum effort.

A Day of Learning

A no-training day does not mean he gets a lazy day lying idly in the sun. Learning is still happening and this is significant and important for his development.

Surprising Puppy

Surprising Puppy. With obnoxious moments. After introducing the obnoxious puppy as a youngster I am knocked over by the Delightful Young Man he is turning into……

Obnoxious Puppy

The delight of your new puppy is probably going to last a few weeks, maybe four if you are lucky. When 12 weeks old hits, and you will feel a slam, the Delight is going to demonstrate ungrateful, obnoxious traits.


Preparing before you train and the final check list

More than words

We expect our dogs to understand the meaning of words and signals, but if you have ever worked with computers you will know that what you say doesn’t always turn into an actionable response.

Not all lures contain food

“the direct use of the reinforcer to elicit the behaviour”
This should always be foremost in our mind, in that many alternatives lures are available.

Remote lures

Lures at a distance, separated from hands, pockets . Using reward stations, patterns, containers

1 Comment

  1. Iris Maxfield

    I could not bring myself to sit silently whilst my dogs “tried to work it out”. It seemed like they were supposed to wriggle around with discomfort and non-information until they stumbled, by luck, on the right answer.

    Could never understand why it became so popular to sit in silents, waiting to see what the dog may offer, with what ever was left on the floor.
    This would cause me to bark with frustration.

    The look of dog-logic when “it does not compute” Love this photo.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News on courses, articles and stuff you don't want to miss.